La Prensa San Diego
Commentary

No Decent Reason for 2,000 Dead in Afghanistan

Published:
Updated:
2 min read

This past week marked a grisly milestone in Afghanistan: The 2,000th U.S. service member has now died there.
And the pace of those deaths has increased, with Obama’s surge bringing about a surge of U.S. deaths. As the New York Times notes, it took about nine years of war to claim the first 1,000 U.S. soldiers and Marines. And it took just a little more than two years to slay the second thousand.

Just in the last week alone, nine U.S. servicemen have died at the hands of Afghan security forces who are supposed to be our allies.

President Obama needs to ask himself, as I’m sure many of our servicemen and their families are asking themselves, “Why are we over there if even our so-called friends are killing us?”

There are now more than twice as many U.S. service members in Afghanistan today than on the day George W. Bush left office.

And the ostensible reasons for keeping them just get murkier and murkier.

Osama bin Laden, after all, is dead. And he was killed not in Afghanistan but in Pakistan.

Defenders of the war say we need to stay there to keep the Taliban from coming back to power. But Karzai himself has endorsed a code of conduct by the country’s Islamic council that approves of husbands beating their wives under Sharia law.

The United States is not at war with Afghanistan for humanitarian reasons.

It is there because Afghanistan borders Iran to the West and China to the East: two countries in the Pentagon’s sights. And it is there because Afghanistan is a transport route for oil from the stans of the former Soviet Union down to the Arabian Sea.

Article - Uber

These are the real reasons the United States is at war with Afghanistan. But these are not decent reasons for letting 2,000 U.S. service members perish.

Matthew Rothschild is the editor of The Progressive (http://www.progressive.org/)

Local news, once a week.

Get La Prensa's most important stories delivered directly to your inbox.

In this article

Latest articles

https://laprensa-media.laprensa.workers.dev/pic_JRodriguezKUSI.jpg
NC’s Rodriguez Claimed SDSU Degree on City Applications
Councilman listed SDSU degree but now admits he never graduated....
05 Oct, 2026
-
5 min read
https://laprensa-media.laprensa.workers.dev/pic_RBaileyGreets.jpg
ENDORSEMENT: Richard Bailey for San Diego City Council
Bailey is a local businessman and former Mayor of Coronado committed to balancing the City budget without raising taxes....
03 Oct, 2026
-
4 min read
https://laprensa-media.laprensa.workers.dev/pic_SDMuniAirport1956.jpg
PERSPECTIVE: All SD Airports Should Be Run by Airport Authority
Four different agencies separately run the 11 public airports in San Diego County, but they should all be combined into the Airport Authority....
01 Oct, 2026
-
6 min read